AI Receptionists for Law Firms: Bar Rules and Real Costs
Can a legal AI receptionist answer your law firm's calls? What Florida Op. 24-1, ABA Op. 512 and Rule 5.3 require, plus dated prices from six vendors.
Hellospark · Hellospark
8 min read · · Updated
Disclaimer. This article is general information for lawyers about technology. It is not legal or ethics advice. Hellospark is a technology consultancy, not a law firm. Check the rules and opinions of every jurisdiction where you are licensed, and read each vendor's current terms yourself. This post was drafted with AI assistance and reviewed by the Hellospark team, who checked every primary source named below. It does not include a personal first-hand anecdote.
In this article · 9 sections
- What does an AI receptionist do for a solo law firm?
- What do the bar rules say about AI receptionists?
- How do you write a compliant intake script?
- How much does an AI receptionist cost?
- Is an AI receptionist worth it for a solo lawyer?
- Should you use an AI or a human answering service?
- Can an AI receptionist make outbound calls?
- Want help setting one up?
- Sources
- Frequently asked questions
If you’re a solo lawyer, missed calls are missed clients. But a legal AI receptionist comes with a catch most vendor roundups skip: the bar rules decide what it may say. This guide covers those rules for law firms and shows what six services charged when we read their pricing pages.
What does an AI receptionist do for a solo law firm?
An AI receptionist answers your phone line (and sometimes web chat) when you can’t. Typical jobs:
- Answer
- Picks up every call, including after hours, and greets the caller.
- Screen
- Asks factual questions: name, contact details, type of matter, the other parties' names for a conflict check.
- Book
- Puts a consultation on your calendar.
- Message
- Sends you a summary or transcript.
What it must not do: give legal advice, tell a caller whether they have a case, present fees as advice, or promise that you’ll take the matter. ABA Formal Opinion 512 puts it plainly: lawyers “may not leave it to GAI tools alone to offer legal advice to clients, negotiate clients’ claims, or perform other functions that require a lawyer’s personal judgment or participation” (ABA Formal Op. 512).
What do the bar rules say about AI receptionists?
Four points matter for a receptionist script:
- Say it’s an AI. Florida Ethics Opinion 24-1: “Generative AI chatbots that communicate with clients or third parties must comply with restrictions on lawyer advertising and must include a disclaimer indicating that the chatbot is an AI program and not a lawyer or employee of the law firm” (Florida Bar Op. 24-1).
- Keep intake factual. Citing its older Opinion 88-6, Florida says nonlawyer intake should clearly identify nonlawyer status, limit questions to factual information, and refer legal questions to the lawyer. The opinion adds that this guidance “is especially useful as law firms increasingly utilize website chatbots for client intake” (Op. 24-1 PDF).
- Watch for accidental clients. A lawyer “should be wary of utilizing an overly welcoming generative AI chatbot that may provide legal advice, fail to immediately identify itself as a chatbot, or fail to include clear and reasonably understandable disclaimers,” because a prospective-client or lawyer-client relationship could form without the lawyer knowing (Op. 24-1 PDF).
- Supervise it like staff. ABA Model Rule 5.3(b) says a lawyer with direct supervisory authority over a nonlawyer “shall make reasonable efforts to ensure that the person’s conduct is compatible with the professional obligations of the lawyer” (ABA Model Rule 5.3). Opinion 512 applies this to outside AI providers: check vendor credentials, security policies, confidentiality agreements and conflicts screening, and notes that “these concepts also apply to GAI providers and tools” (ABA Formal Op. 512).
For the full Florida picture, see our florida bar ai rules checklist. Oregon Formal Opinion 2026-208 reaches the same disclaimer conclusion and adds two intake steps: have a responsible lawyer automatically notified so they can promptly review chatbot conversations, and promptly enter chatbot prospects into conflict checks under RPC 1.18 (Oregon Formal Op. 2026-208). If you also record consultations, our AI notetaker guide covers recording-consent rules.
Texas Opinion 705 doesn’t mention chatbots or receptionists. It does say a lawyer must protect client confidential information under Rule 1.05 before using any generative AI tool, including “reviewing and potentially renegotiating the ‘terms of service’” (Texas Op. 705). Callers often share confidential facts, so read the vendor’s terms first. See our guide to Texas Ethics Opinion 705, and for how plans and settings affect confidentiality, can lawyers use ChatGPT.
California lawyers should read our California State Bar AI guidance and SB 574 checklist.

How do you write a compliant intake script?
Build the script in this order:
- Disclosure first. Open with a line such as: “Hi, you’ve reached [Firm]. I’m an AI assistant, not a lawyer or a member of the firm’s staff.” (This wording follows Florida’s disclaimer requirement; adjust it to your state.)
- Factual questions only. Name, phone, email, type of matter, key dates, how they heard of you.
- Conflict-check hand-off. Collect the names of the other parties and tell the caller the firm checks for conflicts before any consultation.
- No advice, ever. If the caller asks a legal question, the assistant says the lawyer will answer it and moves on.
- No promises. No “we’ll take your case,” no outcome talk.
- Close with a callback. “The lawyer will review this and call you back.” Then send the summary to you.

How much does an AI receptionist cost?
These are the plans shown on each vendor’s own pricing page, monthly billing, read on Nov 3 and rechecked Nov 10, 2026. Prices change often; check before you buy. Call-based, minute-based and flat plans aren’t directly comparable, so the unit is listed with each price.
| Vendor | Billed by | Plans shown (rechecked Nov 10, 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Smith.ai AI Receptionist | Calls | Free $0 (25 calls, then $3.00/call); Pro $150/mo (75 calls, $2.00/call); Enterprise from $500/mo (300 calls) |
| NextPhone | Flat | Pro $199/mo, Growth $299/mo, Scale $599/mo; unlimited calls, no per-minute charges (vendor’s claim) |
| Upfirst | Calls | Starter $24.95/mo (30 calls), Premium $59.95 (90), Pro $159.95 (300), Scale $299 (600); annual about 20% less |
| Dialzara | Minutes | Lite $29 (60 min), Pro $99 (220 min), Plus $199 (500 min), Elite $349 (1,000 min); overage $0.48–$0.35/min |
| Goodcall | Flat tiers | Starter $79, Growth $129, Scale $299 per month |
| Ruby (human receptionists) | Minutes | 50 min $250/mo, 100 min $395, 200 min $720, 500 min $1,725 (smaller tiers read Oct 23; page hides them from scripts) |
We don’t rank these as “best.” To choose, test each against five questions:
- Call volume: how many calls a month, and how long are they?
- After-hours share: how many calls come in when you can’t answer?
- Intake complexity: can it ask your conflict-check questions in order?
- Practice software: does it connect to the tool you use, such as Clio, MyCase or Lawmatics?
- Disclosure control: can you set the exact opening line yourself?
An AI receptionist is one part of the admin stack. For email, calendar and intake tools next to it, see the best AI for solo attorneys.
Is an AI receptionist worth it for a solo lawyer?
It depends on how many calls you miss. Count them for two weeks: calls to voicemail, after-hours calls and hang-ups. Then compare the cost per call. On the pages we read, Smith.ai Pro works out to $2.00 a call (75 calls for $150), Upfirst Starter to about $0.83 (30 calls for $24.95), and NextPhone is a flat $199 with unlimited inbound calls (vendor’s claim). If you rarely miss calls, a cheap plan for after hours may be all you need.
Should you use an AI or a human answering service?
An AI plan usually costs less per call and answers around the clock. A human service like Ruby costs more per minute (see the table) but handles upset or confused callers with a person’s judgment. Some firms use both: AI after hours, people during the day. Either way, Rule 5.3 supervision applies, and the same script rules hold.
Can an AI receptionist make outbound calls?
Be careful here. In Declaratory Ruling FCC 24-17 (adopted Feb 2, 2024), the FCC said the TCPA’s rules on “artificial or prerecorded voice” calls cover AI-generated voices (FCC 24-17). So outbound AI callbacks or reminders generally need the called person’s prior express consent, unless an emergency purpose or exemption applies. Answering inbound calls is a different situation.

Want help setting one up?
We configure the receptionist and intake script with you in a 1-hour AI setup ($100), so you get your evenings back without missing calls. Not sure it fits? Book a free 15-min fit call or see all booking options.
See how we work with solo lawyers and small firms.
For background on what an AI agent is versus a fixed automation, see our plain-English guide.
Sources
- The Florida Bar, Ethics Opinion 24-1 (Jan 19, 2024) and full-text PDF. Checked Oct 23, 2026.
- Oregon State Bar, Formal Opinion 2026-208: Chatbots and AI Agent Communications (approved by the Board of Governors, February 2026). Checked Oct 26, 2026.
- American Bar Association, Formal Opinion 512: Generative Artificial Intelligence Tools (July 29, 2024). Checked Oct 23, 2026.
- American Bar Association, Model Rule 5.3: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistance. Checked Oct 23, 2026.
- Texas Professional Ethics Committee, Opinion 705 (2025). Checked Nov 10, 2026.
- Federal Communications Commission, Declaratory Ruling FCC 24-17 (adopted Feb 2, 2024; released Feb 8, 2024).
- Vendor pricing pages, read Oct 23, rechecked Nov 3 and Nov 10, 2026 (Ruby’s tiers are hidden from scripts; last read Oct 23): Smith.ai, NextPhone, Upfirst, Dialzara, Goodcall, Ruby.
Frequently asked questions
Does an AI receptionist have to say it's an AI?
In Florida, yes. Ethics Opinion 24-1 says generative AI chatbots that communicate with clients or third parties must include a disclaimer that the chatbot is an AI program and not a lawyer or employee of the firm. Other states differ, but saying it up front is the safe default.
Can an AI receptionist book consultations for a law firm?
Booking is a factual, scheduling task, so it fits within the intake limits Florida describes (factual questions only, no legal advice). The lawyer should still run a conflict check before the consultation and decide whether to take the matter.
Is what callers tell an AI receptionist confidential?
Information from prospective clients is protected under Model Rule 1.18(b), as ABA Formal Opinion 512 notes. Before you sign up, read the vendor's terms and privacy policy, check how long recordings and transcripts are kept, and make sure the vendor is bound to keep them confidential.
How much does an AI receptionist cost a month?
On the six vendor pages we read on Nov 3, 2026, plans ran from a free tier (Smith.ai, 25 calls) to $599/month (NextPhone Scale), with per-call, per-minute and flat plans. A human service like Ruby started at $250/month for 50 minutes. Recheck prices before you buy.
Is an AI receptionist worth it for a solo law firm?
It is if you miss calls that could become clients. Count missed and after-hours calls for two weeks, then compare cost per call. On vendor pages we read on Nov 10, 2026, that ran from about $0.83 a call (Upfirst Starter) to $2.00 a call (Smith.ai Pro), or a flat $199/month with unlimited calls (NextPhone).
Does Texas allow AI receptionists for law firms?
Texas Opinion 705 doesn't address chatbots or receptionists directly. It allows generative AI if the lawyer understands the tool and protects client confidential information under Rule 1.05, which includes reviewing the vendor's terms of service. Script it like any nonlawyer assistant: factual intake only, no legal advice.
Can a legal AI receptionist give legal advice?
No. ABA Formal Opinion 512 says lawyers may not leave it to AI tools alone to offer legal advice or do work that needs a lawyer's judgment. The receptionist should collect facts, book the consult and pass legal questions to the lawyer.
Want AI set up for your work?
One 1:1 video hour with a founder to set up AI for your admin. $100, paid when you book.
Get plain-English AI tips for your business
Simple guides to using AI for your admin, written by the two founders. No spam; about one email a month.